Can AI actually increase your effectiveness at work?

Strategies for making AI actually useful

✨ Hey there this is a free edition of next play’s newsletter, where we share under-the-radar opportunities to help you figure out what’s next in your journey. Join our private Slack community here and access $1000s of dollars of product discounts here.

---

Three months after I started using ChatGPT at work, I felt like I had discovered a superpower. Emails got written faster, research projects that used to take hours were done in minutes, and presentations came together with half the usual effort. I was crushing my to-do list and felt incredibly productive.

But something bothered me. I was still doing the same work—just faster.

I was seeing other people online sharing work that seemed fundamentally different from what I was producing. They weren't just writing faster—they were building things I didn't even know were possible. Creating custom tools, developing new capabilities, solving problems I wouldn't have even attempted.

At first, I assumed they had access to different AI tools or some technical knowledge I lacked. But the more I dug in, the more I realized they were often using the same ChatGPT interface I was. Yet somehow, their approach was completely different.

The people who are becoming indispensable at work have learned to collaborate with AI differently. They're not just getting faster outputs—they're developing new capabilities, solving previously impossible problems, and creating value that didn't exist in their roles before.

The career gap between AI tool users and AI collaboration partners is widening every month. And it has nothing to do with technical skills or which subscription plan you have. It's about fundamentally changing how you work with AI.

The collaboration shift

Here's the difference between treating AI as a tool versus treating it as a thinking partner:

Tool Mindset:

"ChatGPT, write an email to my team about the project deadline." → Get email draft → Copy, paste, send → Done

Partner Mindset:

"Let's think through this communication challenge. The team missed the last deadline, morale is low, and I need to be firm but supportive. What approach would balance accountability with encouragement?" → Discuss different communication strategies → Understand the methodology behind the approach → Learn frameworks you can apply to future leadership challenges

The tool mindset gives you a faster email.

The partner mindset teaches you how to be a better communicator.

So, how do you level up from tool user to collaboration partner?

As a starting point, we need to be honest with ourselves by asking this question whenever we chat with our AI:

"Did I just get a faster result, or did I also learn something I can apply to different situations?"

This single question changes how you think about using AI. Instead of optimizing for speed, you start optimizing for developing capability. Instead of just completing tasks, you're building skills that compound over time.

Once you make this shift, you'll notice that your relationship with work itself starts to change. Problems that used to intimidate you become interesting challenges. Skills you thought were "not for you" become accessible. Your professional identity expands beyond what you thought possible.

The question is: Are you ready to stop using AI and start collaborating with it?

Here's how to make that shift practical. I've identified four specific collaboration workflows that transform how you approach your most common workplace challenges. Each workflow takes a different type of problem—research, decisions, skill gaps, recurring issues—and shows you exactly how to move from tool use to true partnership.

Four high-impact collaboration workflow

If you've made it this far, you're ready to move beyond efficiency and start building capabilities.

Here are four workflows you can learn and apply in your work to collaborate with AI:

1. Use AI to research deeper

Goal: Turn 3-hour research into strategic insights in 30 minutes

The Problem: You need comprehensive understanding of complex topics, but traditional research is slow and often misses connections between sources.

The AI Collaboration Solution:

Instead of asking AI "research X topic for me," collaborate through layers:

• Layer 1: Gather initial sources with citations using your preferred research AI

• Layer 2: Identify patterns and connections across those sources

• Layer 3: Synthesize insights and extract transferable frameworks through collaboration

Workplace Implementation:

When you're researching competitors, don't just ask for a comparison table. Ask AI to identify what strategic assumptions each competitor seems to be making, then discuss which assumptions might be wrong.

When analyzing market trends, don't just get data points. Collaborate with AI to identify what patterns exist that others might be missing, and what frameworks you could develop to spot similar opportunities in adjacent markets.

When preparing for client meetings, don't just ask AI to summarize their company background. Ask it to analyze what challenges someone in their position likely faces, what success metrics they're probably measured on, and what questions would demonstrate you understand their strategic context.

Career Impact:

You become known for insights that others miss because you're not just consuming information—you're building understanding through AI collaboration. Instead of spending hours reading, you spend focused time thinking critically about what the information means.

The Key Collaboration Shift:

From "AI, tell me about X" to "AI, help me understand the strategic implications of what's happening with X and what frameworks I can build from this understanding."

2. Use AI as your decision thinking partner

Goal: Stress-test important decisions with AI methodology analysis.

The Problem: Important decisions made in isolation often miss critical considerations or fail because of assumptions you didn't realize you were making.

The AI Collaboration Solution:

Transform AI from "decision maker" to "decision partner" through systematic stress-testing:

• Ask AI to identify assumptions you're making that might be wrong

• Request analysis from different stakeholder perspectives

• Generate potential failure modes and mitigation strategies

• Extract decision frameworks you can reuse for similar choices

Workplace Implementation:

Before launching a new project, don't just ask AI if it's a good idea. Instead, collaborate: "Here's my thinking on this project. What assumptions am I making that might be flawed? If this project fails, what are the most likely reasons? How would different stakeholders view this decision?"

When considering a career move, don't ask AI "should I take this job?" Ask: "Help me understand what success would require in this role that I might not be considering. What are the hidden challenges people face in positions like this? What questions should I ask in interviews to validate whether this is the right fit?"

When making budget decisions, don't just ask for cost-benefit analysis. Collaborate to understand: "What are the second-order effects of this spending decision? What opportunities might we miss by allocating resources this way? How would this decision look different if our priorities changed in six months?"

Career Impact:

You become known for thoughtful decision-making and strategic thinking. People start coming to you for advice because your decisions consistently account for factors others miss.

The Key Collaboration Shift:

This transforms AI from giving you answers to helping you ask better questions.

3. Use AI to accelerate new skill development

Goal: Learn new professional capabilities with AI as a patient teacher.

The Problem: Your work requires capabilities you don't have, but traditional learning takes too long and doesn't connect to immediate workplace challenges.

The AI Collaboration Solution:

Use AI as a patient teacher who can adapt explanations to your learning style and immediate needs:

• Start with fundamentals, but always connect to real workplace applications

• Practice with actual challenges you're facing, not theoretical examples

• Focus on understanding methodology so you can apply principles independently

• Build frameworks that transfer to different situations

Workplace Implementation:

Instead of taking a formal course in data analysis, collaborate with AI to learn by working on real data from your job. Don't just ask for the analysis—ask AI to explain why it's approaching the problem that way, what other methods exist, and how to recognize which approach works best in different situations.

When you need to learn project management skills, don't just get templates. Work with AI to understand the principles behind different frameworks, then adapt them to your specific workplace culture and constraints.

When developing presentation skills, don't just ask AI to create slides. Collaborate to understand: "What makes presentations compelling for this specific audience? How do successful presenters structure complex information? What are the principles I can apply to different presentation contexts?"

Career Impact:

You become the person who can tackle challenges outside traditional role boundaries. Instead of saying "I don't know how to do that," you become known for figuring things out.

The Key Collaboration Shift:

You shift from consuming AI outputs to building lasting capabilities.

4. Use AI to diagnose problem

Goal: Systematically identify root causes instead of treating symptoms.

The Problem: Teams often solve the wrong problem because they jump to solutions too quickly, treating symptoms rather than addressing underlying issues.

The AI Collaboration Solution:

Use AI as a diagnostic partner to systematically explore problems before solving them:

• Present the surface problem and ask for multiple potential root causes

• Request different analytical frameworks to examine the same issue

• Generate questions that would validate which root cause is actually driving the problem

• Develop systematic approaches for similar diagnostic challenges

Workplace Implementation:

When facing declining performance metrics, don't immediately ask AI for solutions. First, collaborate to understand: "Here's what we're seeing. What are different possible root causes? What data would we need to determine which cause is most likely? What questions should we ask stakeholders to understand their perspective?"

When processes keep breaking down, work with AI to identify patterns: "This type of problem keeps recurring. What are the different systems or assumptions that might be causing this pattern? How can we design experiments to test which factor is most important?"

When team morale is low, don't just ask for team-building activities. Collaborate to diagnose: "What are different reasons teams lose motivation? What signals would indicate which factor is most relevant here? How can we test our assumptions about what's really causing the problem before implementing solutions?"

Career Impact:

You become known for solving problems at their source rather than just managing symptoms. People bring you complex challenges because you consistently identify what's actually causing issues.

The Key Collaboration Shift:

The focus moves from quick fixes to systematic understanding.

The compound effect of these workflows

Each workflow builds capabilities that enhance the others. Research acceleration gives you better context for decision-making. Skill development provides new tools for problem diagnosis. Decision frameworks improve how you apply new skills. Together, they transform you from someone who uses AI for faster outputs into someone who collaborates with AI to tackle increasingly complex challenges.

How to choose your first collaboration workflow

Don't try to master all four workflows at once. The key is starting with the workflow that addresses your biggest current workplace frustration.

Start with Research Acceleration if:

• You regularly feel overwhelmed by information when making decisions

• You spend hours reading but struggle to extract actionable insights

• You need to understand complex topics quickly for client meetings or projects

• You often feel like you're missing important context that others seem to have

Start with Decision Support if:

• You frequently second-guess important choices after making them

• You feel like your decisions often have unexpected consequences

• You're in a role where strategic thinking is becoming more important

• You want to be known for thoughtful, well-reasoned decisions

Start with Skill Development if:

• Your work increasingly requires capabilities outside your original training

• You feel limited by what you "can't do" professionally

• You see opportunities that require skills you don't currently have

• You want to expand what your role can accomplish

Start with Problem Diagnosis if:

• You keep solving the same problems repeatedly

• Your team often implements solutions that don't actually fix underlying issues

• You want to be known as someone who gets to the root of complex challenges

• You find yourself treating symptoms rather than causes

The opportunity ahead

We're living through a unique moment in professional history. AI capabilities are advancing faster than most people's collaboration skills with them. The gap between professionals who treat AI as a tool versus those who collaborate with AI as a thinking partner is widening every month.

Right now, while most people are still figuring out how to use AI for basic efficiency, early adopters are developing capabilities that seemed impossible just two years ago. They're solving problems that didn't have solutions, building skills outside their original capabilities, and creating professional value that didn't exist in their roles before.

The window for competitive advantage is still open, but it's narrowing rapidly.

The people who learn to collaborate with AI now—while it still feels new and uncertain—will be the ones setting the pace for everyone else. They'll be the people others turn to when complex challenges arise. They'll be the ones creating opportunities rather than just responding to them.

Your next move doesn't have to be dramatic. Pick one workflow that addresses a frustration you're already feeling. Spend fifteen minutes this week asking AI "why did you approach it that way?" instead of just taking the output and moving on.

That curiosity will naturally pull you toward deeper collaboration. And once you experience what it feels like to think alongside AI instead of just using it, you'll understand why some professionals are becoming irreplaceable while others worry about being automated.

The future belongs to the collaborators, not the users.

Which future are you building?